Hall of Fame Athletes
- 1953 Football Team
- 1974 Baseball Team
- Allen, Bill
- Bailey, David
- Baker, Scott
- Bartley, Bill
- Bennet, Kerm
- Benninger, Brian
- Carrigan, Gordy
- Dulaney, Vern
- Frank, Glen
- Garrison, Debbie
- Glines, Mike
- Hartgraves, Dean
- Herman, Fred
- Hilton, Sheri
- Hoffine, Loyd
- Knotts, Debbie Tally
- McCall, Marnie
- Meunier, Matt
- Moore, Becky
- Morris, Howard
- Neal, Mea Frantz
- Parent, Krista
- Ryan, Marty
- Speasl, Dan
- Summerfield, Darryl
- Titchenal, David
- Tonn, Harvey
- Turner, Randy
- Warren, Leonard
Athletic Hall of Fame
The Crater High School Sports Hall of Fame was established in 1996 by former Crater teacher and coach Dave Orr.
Those considered for induction are people who excelled in athletics while at Crater, participated at the collegiate level, and continued their accomplishments into their professional lives.
Originally created for individual athletes, teams and coaches are now considered for induction.
Criteria for nomination are as follows:
- Excelled in athletics while at Crater
- Attended and participated in athletics at the collegiate level
- Continued to be successful in their professional lives
- Graduated from Crater at least 10 years ago
All nominations are reviewed by a committee and those selected will be notified and ultimately inducted in the Crater High School Sports Hall of Fame.